Halloween Treat Recipes: Witch Hat Surprise Cookies

I’ve been thinking lots about making some fun Halloween Treat recipes this year. My latest? Witch Hat Surprise Cookies
These are pretty easy to make and you can fill them (or not) with extra candy delights!
What you need:

Package Oreo Ice Cream Cones

Purple Funfetti Frosting (Really, you can do any color, we just thought the purple with green and black looked super witchy)

Famous Chocolate Wafers (You could also use any flat cookie that’s a dark brown/black color)

Candy Corn for filling (or anything you want to fill with)


First, you dunk the end of your cone into the frosting to coat the edges for the sprinkles to stick. (Or use a spoon- we dunked)


Roll your cone end in sprinkles (the kids are doing the tips here- same idea though)


Next, fill your cone with candy corn

(Not sure where the photo went for this step, but put a dollop of frosting onto the flat cookie so the cone will stick to it and attach cone)


Voila! Witch Hat Surprise Cookies!

Check out our Candy Corn Crunch Recipe too!

About the author: I’m a 30-something mom to three, brand ambassador. content creator, social media maven, blogger extraordinaire, earth lover, butcher, baker, candlestick maker (or something along those lines) – love word games, crafting, cake decorating or shooting pictures.

19 comments… add one
  • These are so adorable! What a fun idea for Halloween!!! Love it!!!
  • Those are fun and easy and would be a big hit at a party.
  • You know, before seeing this recipe I had no idea that Oreo makes ice cream cones. Now that I know this I must try them, chocolate ice cream cones!! Thank you for this revelation!!
  • Yum!! I'm not a fan of Candy Corn so I'll be filling the cones with something else, maybe jelly beans or gummy bears.
  • I love this idea! these are very cute. Im saving this recipe, my kids will love these. Thanks for sharing.

Leave a Comment