Sell out your Bake Sale with these bake sale recipe ideas!

Do the words “Bake Sale Goods Needed” strike fear in your heart like they do mine?  I always panic. What if I mess up? What if I don’t make the prettiest treats? What if no one buys my stuff?  Well, I asked some of my blogging friends what THEIR no-fail Bake Sale recipe ideas are…and came up with some pretty awesome ideas.  You’ll find all kinds of ideas from the everyday sugar cookies to even dog treats (but hey, why can’t our poochies enjoy a nice bake sale item?)

no fail bake sale recipesCookies:

The Best Chocolate Chip Cookies Ever. Maybe. Probably. This Mama Loves

3 Ingredient Peanut Butter Cookies– Coupons are GREAT

Thumbprint Cookies Just Like June

Chocolate Chip Pecan Cookies The Rebel Chick

Chocolate Chip Cookies Our Family World
*Gluten Free Razzle-Dazzle PB&J Cookies Kids are Grown
*Gluten Free Nutella Chocolate Cookies Kids Fun Reviewed

Easy Sugar Cookies Growing Up Gabel

Salted Butterscotch Cookies Momma Rambles


Peanut Butter Fudge Bars Outnumbered 3 to 1

Pecan Brownie Bars This Mama Loves

Cake Mix Cookie Bars Dear Crissy

Butter Tart Squares Canadian Moms Cook

Salted Brown Butter Rice Krispy Treats This Mama Loves

Chocolate Mint Brownies 7 on a Shoestring
**Vegan Chocolate Fudge Slap Dash Mom

Oatmeal Carmelitos This Mama Loves

Bread & Rolls

Nutella-Bacon Crescent Rolls Around My Family Table

Soft Pretzel Bread Single Mom on a Budget

Fruits & Pies

New York Style Cherry Cheesecake  When is Dinner

Pecan Butter Tarts Simply Stacie

Mini Hand-Held Fruit Pies Sweep Tight

Cakes and Cupcakes

Copycat Hostess Cupcakes Tammilee Tips

Pink Lemonade Cupcakes  MamaBee

Cookies & Cream Cupcakes My Organized Chaos

Strawberry Tres-Leches Cakes in Canning Jars Hot Mama in the City

Easy S’mores Cupcakes– Thrifty Jinxy

White Chocolate Chip Mocha Cupcakes Mom with a Dot Com

Pink Cool Whip Frosted Chocolate Cupcakes The Suburban Mom

Muffins, Donuts & Breakfast Goodies

Easy Crumb-Topped Banana Muffins A Mom’s Take

The Best Cinnamon Buns Ever Bewitchin Kitchen

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Muffins  Day by Day in Our World

Chocolate Chip Muffins Nicki’s Random Musings

Baked Donuts Formula Mom

Blueberry Coffee Cake This Mama Loves


End of the Rainbow Crunch This Mama Loves

Kettle Corn Jade Louise Designs

Dogs & Cats

Homemade Dog Treats Two Little Cavaliers

What are YOUR favorite Bake Sale recipe ideas? Share, please! 

About the author: I’m a 30-something mom to three, brand ambassador. content creator, social media maven, blogger extraordinaire, earth lover, butcher, baker, candlestick maker (or something along those lines) – love word games, crafting, cake decorating or shooting pictures.

20 comments… add one
  • My tips for a successful bake sale are to try and make as many different things as you can, so that people with different dietary restrictions/allergies can buy something. Ex: sugar free, gluten free, or nut free.
  • Cupcakes and brownies are great sale items.
  • I thought there was supposed to be a giveaway, I clicked the link on your right sidebar, but I tried 3 different browsers and no form comes up. :(
    • P.S. This one ends today so no time to get any entries in.
  • Loaded oatmeal cookies, Ina's brownies and pretty cupcakes always go over well.
  • We love making peppermint cheesecakes. Little mini ones.
  • Lots of good recipes, Yummy! Thanks
  • My favorite are fudge brownies with chocolate chips.
  • While I have not particpated in a bake sale, I have bought plenty of treats. I like cookies and cupcakes.
  • Oh my... sweet treats are my absolute favorite thing ever!
  • Yum! I looooooooooove baked goods. Thanks for giving me some great inspiration for my sweet tooth!
  • I have never been involved in a bake sale, however, if I were, these all look like they would sell like hotcakes!! Very yummy :)
  • ooh, these look so good. Thanks for the idea and recipes. I gotta try.
  • These all look so tempting! Off to check them out!
  • Thank you for placing all of these receipes in one central location for easy access. I especially like the recipe for the Homemade Dog Treats.
  • That was great of you to put all of these recipes under one compilation. I am in the baking mood so I am going to pick one out and go make it right now (ingredients willing!).
  • So delicious, thanks for compiling all of these :)
  • lots of good recipes, thanks
  • We just planned a bake sale for this spring Im saving this!
  • These all look yummy. Great ideas.

Leave a Comment